**Prompt: Stroboscopic, Fencing, Sports, Multi-exposure, mild, motion**
1. Does the image meet your expectations?
No really what I was looking for, but it has its own style. I have never seen images created by computer with so organic textures, which gives a feeling of analog film.
2. To what degree does your text query influence the generated image?
The image matches my text description pretty well, except for it kind of correlates the fencing with physical fence, shown as white bars in the image. Things being said, it is still quite different from the image in my mind - Chronophotograph by Étienne-Jules Marey.
3. What is the style of the image, and why do you think it has produced that?
Image looks like a motion blurred film photo. The motion blur should be caused by the keyword “motion”. The silver-grain-like texture might be caused by keyword “stroboscopic and multi-exposure”.
4. Any thoughts about how the visual elements in the image are organized
Too symmetrical than my taste.
5. How would you change the query? to achieve what difference?
I would change “fencing” to “fencer”. I will also change the aspect ratio to 16:9.
6. Any other comments?
I like the middle person being sharp while the other two people being blurred.
7. On a scale of 5 - from 5 being GREAT to 1 being LOW your rating of the result
4/5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prompt: chronophotograph, stroboscopic, fencing, sports, multi-expos
1. Does the image meet your expectations?
It surprised me. It is very abstract, though still different from what I imagine.
2. To what degree does your text query influence the generated image?
I misspelled the [multi-exposure] as [multi-expos]. The white bars were created because of [fencing], so does the white man.
3. What is the style of the image, and why do you think it has produced that?
The image is abstract, probably there is ambiguity in the word [fencing] and the misspelled word [multi-expos]. The blurred areas should be caused by [chronophotograph][stroboscopic]
4. Any thoughts about how the visual elements in the image are organized
Image follows rule of third and the subject is surrounded by the box. Great composition.
5. How would you change the query? to achieve what difference?
It is kind of an accident. I would reduce the while lines a little bit by change [fencing] to [fencer]
6. Any other comments?
7. On a scale of 5 - from 5 being GREAT to 1 being LOW your rating of the result
4/5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Prompt: **fencers, action scene, win, olympics game, Ilford HP5, sideview
—no ice hockey**
1. Does the image meet your expectations?
Almost met my expectation, but the image was not perfect sideview. The camera was close to one side and further to the other side.
2. To what degree does your text query influence the generated image?
Matched pretty well.
3. What is the style of the image, and why do you think it has produced that?
Black white, motion blur, decisive moment image.
4. Any thoughts about how the visual elements in the image are organized
it looks like typical action scene composition.
5. How would you change the query? to achieve what difference?
I changed [fencers] to [two fencers] to limit the people in the photo to two. It does not work the well. Also, the image doesn’t look silver-grainy of film. I should have add “iso 3200” or “grainy”.
6. Any other comments?
7. On a scale of 5 - from 5 being GREAT to 1 being LOW your rating of the result
4.5/5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
prompt: **two fencers, action scene, olympics game, Ilford HP5, win, sideview**
**+
ice hockeyBOTMidjourney Bottwo fencers, action scene, olympics game, Ilford HP5, score, sideview**
**+
ice hockey**
1. Does the image meet your expectations?
I was expecting a Black White photo because of the Ilford HP5 (name of a type of Black White film), but it ended up with a colored image. Again, I am surprised by the realistic look of the image and the pose of the right person who is taking off his/her helmet. There was also an accidental copy-paste error and caused repetitive words in the prompt.
2. To what degree does your text query influence the generated image?
It matches pretty well, except for the Ilford HP5. I think it was conflicting with olympics game. The background of city was amazing, probably caused by “action scene”. The pose was affected by the “win” keyword.
3. What is the style of the image, and why do you think it has produced that?
realistic, cinematic image. “action scene” caused it.
4. Any thoughts about how the visual elements in the image are organized
it is a little bit unbalanced, the right is too dark and dense and the left is too bright and empty.
5. How would you change the query? to achieve what difference?
I changed sideview to Side-View and it seems resolved the issue with unbalanced composition.
6. Any other comments?
7. On a scale of 5 - from 5 being GREAT to 1 being LOW your rating of the result
4.5/5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
**two fencers, action scene, olympics game, Side-View, flash, moment, clear**
1. Does the image meet your expectations?
No, I was looking for a “clear” image but still gave me the motion blur. I was looking for “side-view” but it was not purely side-view.
2. To what degree does your text query influence the generated image?
Once I removed “Ilford HP5” it becomes colorful. The background looks like a flag of certain country, caused by “olympics game”.
3. What is the style of the image, and why do you think it has produced that?
It looks like sports photography. “Moment” “clear” produced this image of a very exciting moment.
4. Any thoughts about how the visual elements in the image are organized
Pretty typical sports photography composition with very interesting background. The middle area of the background fades out to white which is very interesting.
5. How would you change the query? to achieve what difference?
I removed “Olympic Games” to remove the background.
6. Any other comments?
7. On a scale of 5 - from 5 being GREAT to 1 being LOW your rating of the result
4.5/5
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
prompt: DALL·E 2022-09-30 10.25.11 - Stroboscopic, Chronophotograph, fencing, white suits, illford, side-view, series, long, many
1. Does the image meet your expectations?
It is beyond my expectation.
2. To what degree does your text query influence the generated image?
The image matches the description.
3. What is the style of the image, and why do you think it has produced that?
It looks like the color film in the 70s. Like the first image in this link (
https://imgur.com/gallery/LActU). The “Stroboscopic” keyword caused it but same thing was not produced in Midjourney. I think the dataset DALLE-2 used must contain the photographs of 70s.
4. Any thoughts about how the visual elements in the image are organized
I like the near-symmetric composition. It reminds me of work of Georges Méliès’s film.
5. How would you change the query? to achieve what difference?
I added Georges Méliès’s name to the query to make the image looks more like his work.
6. Any other comments?
7. On a scale of 5 - from 5 being GREAT to 1 being LOW your rating of the result
5/5